This article contains major spoilers for The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.
It’s time to take another trip to Panem as Sunrise On The Reaping – the most recent instalment in the Hunger Games series of books by Suzanne Collins – receives the big-screen treatment.
Directed by Francis Lawrence, who has helmed all but the first movie in the hugely successful Hunger Games movie franchise, Sunrise On The Reaping explores an earlier iteration of the games than the original film trilogy, much like its 2023 predecessor, The Ballad Of Songbirds & Snakes.
This time around, the focus is on Haymitch Abernathy, a 16-year-old tribute who grows up to mentor Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson’s characters in the original trilogy. Previously, he was portrayed by Woody Harrelson, and in this film he’s played by Joseph Zada.
The Sunrise On The Reaping book was published only last year and met mostly with acclaim – however, the movie adaptation has already divided critics.
And as with any book-to-film adaptation, there are a few things that are missing or have been changed for the screen. Here are seven of the most noticeable differences between the new movie and its source material…
Haymitch’s birthday ‘celebration’ plays out a little bit differently on screen compared to the book
In the novel version of Sunrise On The Reaping, much is made of the fact that the annual reaping ceremony unfortunately falls on Haymitch’s birthday. In fact, once Haymitch is selected for the games and sent off to The Capitol, an extravagant birthday cake is delivered to his carriage by Plutarch Heavensbee, complete with a birthday song.
This is very much a “read-the-room” kind of moment, in which Plutarch and the other Capitol citizens spectacularly fail to understand why Haymitch is categorically not in the mood to celebrate his birthday given his current situation.
Sunrise On The Reaping’s film adaptation, however, omits this cake detail, instead focussing on the tributes getting to know their handlers.
The treatment of Lou-Lou by The Capitol in the film isn’t depicted as harshly as in the novel
In the Sunrise On The Reaping novel, Lou-Lou is an enigmatic child brought in by President Snow to replace District 12 tribute Louella McCoy, who was originally chosen at the reaping, but accidentally killed during the procession of the tributes before the games even began.
Lou-Lou is suspected to be a child of Capitol traitors who has been sentenced to die in the Hunger Games as Louella’s body double. It’s also discovered that Lou-Lou has been fitted with a discreet device in her ear, and another in her chest, that can be used to communicate with her, subdue her and deliver terrific pain if needed.
This is a reminder of the insidious methods of control and subjugation that the Capitol exercises over its enemies, and even the children of those enemies.
Some of the especially graphic deaths have been removed from the movie adaptation
At this point, it’s not exactly a shocker that some of the tributes meet a particularly grisly end in the Hunger Games arena.
In the book, the character of Ampert is eaten alive by genetically-engineered squirrels which strip him to the bone: Haymitch remarks upon there only being a skeleton left when he gets to Ampert.
Similarly, Wellie – a District 6 tribute – is beheaded by District 1’s Silka, who holds up Wellie’s severed head to show Haymitch.
Director Francis Lawrence told content creator Florence Rose that there were certain book moments he was not able to show, lest the film lose its 12A age rating. Instead, he chose to focus on the “emotional intensity” of the story, rather than the “graphic detail of the violence” in the novels.
A giant porcupine ‘mutt’ that takes out three tributes did not make the final cut of the film
Fans of the book will recall that there is a large alliance in the 50th Hunger Games that includes several districts, including Haymitch’s. They are called “the Newcomers”, and they’re designed to face off against the tributes referred to as “the Careers”, who are more often trained from an early age for the Hunger Games and volunteer to take part.
Because of this alliance, many competitors end up dying at the hands of “mutts” in the games – fearsome, genetically-engineered creatures that gamemakers send into the arena to hunt tributes.
One such mutt is a bear-sized porcupine that ends up killing three tributes before being lured away by Haymitch and Maysilee.
Lawrence confirmed to Bustle that this sequence was filmed, but was cut from the movie because it didn’t add anything in terms of character or thematics.
“Initially, when we screened the movie for people, we had that sequence in,” he explained. “There’s probably a five-to-10 minute-stretch in there around the porcupine, which people might remember [from the book]. That all got lifted out.”
The biggest missing detail from the book in the film is Maysilee’s touching ‘I’ll be your sister’ speech
Fellow District 12 tribute Maysilee Donner – played by Mckenna Grace in the movie – does not initially click with Haymitch (or, indeed, many of the other characters in Sunrise On The Reaping) due to her barbed and occasionally arrogant facade.
However, there is a moment towards the end of the book where Maysilee and Haymitch trade stories about their siblings back home, and Maysilee affirms that she will be Haymitch’s new “sister”, after he disclosed that his mother once miscarried twin girls.
Maysilee is a twin herself, and it’s a wonderful tear-jerking moment designed to underscore the trauma-bonding that goes on between tributes in the games.
It’s not just tributes who get killed in the arena in the book version of Sunrise On The Reaping
One of the major plots in the novel is Haymitch’s attempted sabotage of the arena whilst he is in the games, aided by fellow tribute Ampert and mentors Wiress and Beetee.
Though he is largely unsuccessful, he causes enough damage to warrant three low-level gamemakers (basically janitors) to enter the arena themselves and fix things.
In one particularly dramatic scene, they encounter tributes Haymitch, Silka, Maysilee and Maritte, and the latter two end up killing the three gamemakers.
This seals the fates of both Maysilee and Maritte, but Lawrence felt the scene wasn’t necessary.
“That janitor sequence… we shot it, but there was a lot of discussion around it,” he admitted, before hinting that both this and the sequence with the porcupine mutt could be included as deleted scenes when Sunrise On The Reaping is released digitally.
There isn’t so much of Haymitch being paraded around The Capitol after he wins the games in the film
One thing that hasn’t been explored too thoroughly in The Hunger Games movies is the commodification of winning tributes by The Capitol after their games are over.
However, we glimpse a little bit of this at the end of the book when Haymitch is put in a giant cage to be gawped at at a party for the amusement of his “adoring” fans in The Capitol.
This doesn’t make it to the film, but there is some exploration of Haymitch’s declining mental state post-games, although it mostly occurs back home in District 12.
The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping is in cinemas now.