You’ve just woken up and your body’s craving coffee. You drink the first cup and desire a second, only to discover it doesn’t taste as good as the first.
Maybe it doesn’t taste as fresh. Maybe it tastes stale. Have you ever noticed that the first cup of coffee you drink during the day – whether it’s morning, afternoon or night – hits differently than the second cup?
New York Times staff writer Taffy Brodesser-Akner also wondered the same thing. In 2020, she tweeted: “The first cup of coffee is so good that it encourages the second cup, but the second cup is always bad. Why??”
She received more than 170 replies.
According to a few coffee experts, several factors, including the caffeine fix, are involved.
“For most people, the first cup is enjoyed in the morning,” Ashlee Eastwood-Quinn, head of coffee at Rave Coffee, told HuffPost.
“Unless you’ve had caffeine late into the previous evening, a good portion of it has cleared from your system overnight, so you’re likely experiencing a slight caffeine withdrawal. The smell and taste of that first cup are all tied up in relieving that withdrawal, which triggers a pleasure response.”
Eastwood-Quinn further explained that with the second cup “the reward response isn’t as strong,” as the first cup probably satisfied the cravings.
Swedish DJ and producer Alesso really relishes that first cup:
However, actor Albert Brooks understood the decrease in rewards when in 2020 he tweeted:
Drinking coffee is a sensory experience, and the first whiff of coffee enhances that first cup, too. “Aroma is a big part of coffee’s appeal, and your nose quickly habituates to stimuli,” explained Michael Cramer, founder and product developer at Lardera Coffee. “After the initial exposure, your perception of coffee’s aroma fades, making your senses less attuned to what initially wowed you.”
“Your taste and smell also adapt quickly to repeated exposure, so if you drink two cups close together, your receptors are already a little fatigued by the second one,” Eastwood-Quinn said. “The delicate notes you get from a specialty coffee, like fruit, florals or sweetness, are often the first to fade.”
Matt Woodburn-Simmonds, co-founder of the coffee-reviewing site Home Coffee Expert, said he thinks his palate is “fresher” before breakfast. “I can taste more clearly without other food or drink muddying the water,” he said. “This makes that first cup taste all the more delicious for me: the fruit, sweet spice and gentle acidity are just easier to tease out than they are with the second, third or 10th cup of the day.”
Hopefully no one is drinking 10 cups a day, but part of the fun of looking forward to that first cup has to do with the daily ritual of brewing coffee.
“Manually grinding your beans, hearing the sound of the kettle or Moka pot boiling, and the smell of coffee all form part of a ritual that builds up anticipation around that first sip,” Eastwood-Quinn said.
“But by the second cup that build-up has often gone, and you’re drinking it while you’re busy or focused on work, so there isn’t as much of a psychological payoff.”
“You can never quite recreate the experience of that very first sip,” said Robyn Bordes, co-owner of the Greenwich, Connecticut, cafe Love You a Latte. “We always say the first cup wakes you up, but it’s really the ritual that makes you fall in love with coffee.”
Milky Way via Getty Images
Once the sadness sets in of the first cup disappearing, the coffee drinker must stare into the void of an empty cup. What do they have to anticipate, if anything? How can they make that second – or third or fifth – cup of coffee taste brighter?
“The second cup may be improved by ice cream. If you call it affogato, it sounds less like ‘I ate ice cream for breakfast,’” one person humorously replied to Brodesser-Akner’s tweet.
Ice cream always works, but so does water. “We recommend sparkling water between cups of coffee to help cleanse your palate,” Bordes said. “The carbonation can help rinse away lingering flavors and leave your mouth feeling refreshed, allowing you to better appreciate the rich flavors and aromas of your second cup.”
All isn’t lost! Maybe it’s possible to enjoy the second cup as much as the first. Eastwood-Quinn had another recommendation: Use different brew methods for the next cup.
“Make a cafetière at home, then go out for a flat white,” she said. “Or have someone else make the coffee for you. Psychologically, this makes me enjoy my coffee in a whole different way.”