Consortium underwriting arrangements at Lloyd’s could represent as much as 15% of the insurance market’s total premium income by 2030, according to a study by Howden Re, the reinsurance broking and capital markets advisory business of international insurance group Howden.
The research points to increasing reliance on collaborative underwriting structures as syndicates seek to expand their capacity, improve distribution and access specialist capabilities.
The report estimates that premiums generated through Lloyd’s consortia could exceed £11 billion by the end of the decade, reflecting expectations that these arrangements will take on a greater role in the market’s operating structure.
Howden Re gathered views from 64 senior industry executives whose syndicates collectively represent 84% of Lloyd’s estimated gross premium income for 2026. Their responses suggest that consortium business could contribute between 10% and 15% of the market’s gross written premium (GWP) by 2030.
For comparison, Lloyd’s Market Association (LMA) data referenced in the study indicates that consortia accounted for around 7% of market GWP in 2024, having represented just 3% seven years earlier.
The survey suggests that consortium participation has moved beyond a supplementary underwriting activity to become an established element of syndicate business strategies.
More than nine in ten executives surveyed by Howden Re regarded consortium arrangements as commercially advantageous, while approximately four-fifths said they formed part of their principal business plans.
The findings also demonstrate the extent of participation across Lloyd’s. Some 77% of respondents reported managing at least one consortium as a lead syndicate, while 80% said they provided supporting capacity through follower arrangements.
For lead underwriters, increasing the amount of capacity available on individual risks emerged as the most frequently identified advantage. Howden Re found that 84% of respondents included larger line sizes among their three main reasons for establishing or managing consortia.
Other considerations included maintaining a prominent position in underwriting markets and securing additional revenue through management fees and profit-sharing arrangements.
Tom Gauge, Managing Director, Consortia at Howden Re, stated: “The consortium model has evolved well beyond its traditional role in supporting niche underwriting. What we’re seeing is a fundamental shift in how Lloyd’s syndicates approach leadership, distribution and capital deployment. Consortia are now firmly embedded in business planning. As the market softens, they allow syndicates to strengthen their leadership position, deploy meaningful capacity and generate fee income that is not tied to underwriting risk. The scale of growth anticipated by the market shows just how important this model is becoming.”
The study also examined why syndicates choose to support consortia rather than lead them. According to Howden Re, the opportunity to participate in business managed by underwriters with established technical knowledge was the most commonly identified attraction.
Some 86% of those surveyed placed access to specialist product knowledge among the three most valuable aspects of follower participation.
Respondents additionally highlighted the opportunity to participate in carefully selected risks and underwriting portfolios designed to prioritise profitability.
Howden Re found that consortia were favoured over managing general agents (MGAs) and broker-operated facilities as a distribution route for dedicated portfolio solutions businesses.
The research also considered the potential implications for organisations purchasing insurance through Lloyd’s. More than 95% of participating executives believed consortium structures offered advantages to policyholders. The benefits most frequently identified included broader access to available insurance capacity and reduced waiting times for underwriting decisions.
The survey results suggest that interest in establishing additional consortium arrangements is expected to continue even as pricing and competitive conditions develop.
Around 90% of respondents indicated that they expected to place new consortia during the next three years, suggesting that the model is viewed as useful beyond periods of restricted underwriting capacity.
Howden Re’s analysis further indicates that the arrangements could support a clearer separation between syndicates that originate and manage risks and those that provide additional underwriting capacity.
David DeJong, Managing Director, Consortia at Howden Re, commented: “One of the consortium model’s greatest strengths is the alignment it creates between leaders and followers. Syndicates can access proven underwriting expertise and diversified portfolios, while leaders can bring together the capacity needed to compete more effectively and respond to policyholder demand. That alignment is becoming increasingly valuable as Lloyd’s moves towards more clearly defined lead and follow strategies. Consortia are helping to reshape how the market operates, with benefits extending beyond syndicates to the businesses they insure.”
Although the £11 billion projection remains dependent on future market activity, the findings indicate that Lloyd’s participants anticipate a continued increase in consortium business through 2030.
Howden Re’s research suggests that the appeal of these structures is linked not only to the ability to combine underwriting capacity but also to their potential to support specialist risk selection, generate additional income and provide alternative routes for placing insurance business.