Artificial intelligence could influence the financial strength and creditworthiness of insurance companies, although the benefits will depend on how successfully the technology is implemented and managed, according to new research from KBRA, the credit rating agency.
In its report, Beyond the AI Hype: What It Means for Insurer Credit, KBRA examines the implications of AI becoming more deeply embedded in insurance operations, highlighting both the potential financial advantages and the additional risks that could affect insurers’ credit profiles.
The agency suggests that the insurance industry is entering a more significant phase of AI adoption, with companies increasingly seeking to incorporate the technology into everyday operations rather than limiting its use to experimental projects.
However, KBRA maintains that greater investment in AI does not necessarily translate into improved credit quality. Insurers will need to demonstrate that the technology can deliver lasting financial benefits while maintaining effective oversight and protecting their businesses against emerging operational threats.
According to the agency, AI has the potential to change how insurers assess risks, process claims, manage expenditure and interact with customers. Improvements in these areas could strengthen profitability and operational performance, but the financial implications will depend on whether expected efficiencies can be achieved consistently.
KBRA identifies the successful integration of AI into existing business systems as a major challenge. Insurers must ensure that the information supporting AI applications is accurate and accessible, while also establishing appropriate cybersecurity protections, compliance arrangements and performance monitoring.
The agency notes that insurers are progressing at different rates, with some moving towards broader operational deployment while others remain focused on testing potential applications. Consequently, the existence of multiple AI initiatives should not be interpreted as evidence of improved financial performance.
Underwriting and claims operations are expected to be among the areas most likely to demonstrate the financial effects of AI adoption in the near term.
KBRA suggests that more sophisticated risk analysis could help insurers make better underwriting decisions, while automated processing could reduce administrative workloads and accelerate the handling of submissions. AI-assisted fraud detection and improved claims assessment may also help limit unnecessary expenditure and support underwriting profitability.
Nevertheless, the agency cautions that poorly controlled AI systems could produce inaccurate pricing decisions, contribute to unfavourable risk selection or result in inappropriate claims outcomes. These weaknesses could create financial losses, regulatory difficulties and customer-related concerns, potentially undermining the intended benefits of automation.
KBRA considers effective governance central to determining whether AI strengthens or weakens an insurer’s credit position Rather than focusing primarily on how quickly new technology is introduced, the agency places greater importance on the controls used to manage its development and application. Insurers with established model validation processes, reliable data management, documented procedures and appropriate human supervision may be better equipped to identify problems before they become financially significant.
The research also draws attention to the responsibilities of senior management and boards in overseeing AI-related decisions. KBRA indicates that clearly defined accountability, regular monitoring and effective escalation arrangements will be important in ensuring that technology-related risks remain manageable.
Another area of concern is the insurance industry’s growing reliance on external technology businesses. According to KBRA, insurers increasingly depend on specialist AI developers, cloud infrastructure providers, data companies and insurance technology suppliers to support their digital operations. While these relationships can provide access to advanced capabilities, they may also expose insurers to risks beyond their immediate operational control.
The agency expects third-party oversight to become an increasingly important component of insurers’ risk management frameworks, particularly as regulatory scrutiny of automated decision-making develops.
KBRA notes that insurers must be able to demonstrate compliance with applicable insurance regulations and wider legal obligations when using AI-supported systems. Appropriate testing, record-keeping, documentation and supervision will therefore remain essential, regardless of whether the technology is developed internally or supplied by external organisations.
Despite the opportunities presented by AI, KBRA does not expect the introduction of new technology, in isolation, to trigger changes in insurer credit ratings.
Instead, the agency will look for evidence that AI investments are producing sustained improvements in financial and operational results. This could include stronger underwriting performance, lower operating costs, more consistent earnings, improved service delivery and greater resilience against operational disruption.
KBRA will also assess whether insurers experience additional financial pressures from technology expenditure, cybersecurity incidents, model deficiencies or regulatory intervention.
The agency intends to incorporate AI-related developments into its established approach to assessing insurance credit quality, which considers factors such as profitability, earnings consistency, competitive positioning, capital strength, investment exposure and risk management effectiveness.
Where AI contributes to sustained improvements in underwriting results or cost efficiency, KBRA indicates that the developments could have favourable credit implications. Where benefits remain uncertain or have not translated into measurable financial outcomes, the effect may be neutral.
By contrast, significant implementation costs, inadequate controls or failures involving AI systems could place pressure on an insurer’s credit profile.
KBRA’s findings suggest that the longer-term significance of AI for the insurance sector will be determined less by the scale of technology adoption and more by insurers’ ability to demonstrate financial value while controlling the associated risks.
As the technology becomes more widely used, the agency expects differences in implementation, oversight and measurable performance to play an increasingly important role in distinguishing insurers that benefit financially from AI from those facing additional operational and credit challenges.