US tort costs nearly double in nine years, outpacing economic growth and inflation: Triple-I

triple i insurance infromation institute logo

The Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I), a US organisation specialising in research, data and analysis on the insurance and risk sectors, has highlighted the sharp increase in the cost of civil litigation in the United States.

Its latest findings show that tort costs rose from USD $299.7 billion in 2014 to USD $579.7 billion in 2023, almost doubling over nine years and increasing considerably faster than the wider economy and inflation.

According to Triple-I, the average annual growth in tort costs reached 10.38% between 2014 and 2023. This was around twice the annual rate of nominal gross domestic product (GDP) growth, which stood at 5.17%, and almost four times the average inflation rate of 2.74%.

Michel Léonard, Ph.D., CBE, Chief Economist and Data Scientist at Triple-I, highlighted the implications of the figures for the insurance market, stating: “Litigation is outgrowing the economy. That gap doesn’t stay in the courtroom. It lands in claims, reserves and premiums. Every dollar of tort costs adds to insurers’ losses and contributes to higher and less affordable insurance premium rates.”

The findings form part of an analysis drawing on the US Chamber Institute for Legal Reform’s (ILR) 2026 publication, International Tort Costs: A Comparative Analysis of the United States, United Kingdom, EUG5, Australia, and Canada. The report was produced in collaboration with Triple-I and examines tort-related expenditure across several major international markets.

The analysis identifies other liability and personal motor liability as the two largest contributors to US tort costs. In 2023, other liability generated costs of $249.31 billion, while personal auto liability accounted for USD $188.13 billion. Together, these areas represented 75.45% of the country’s total tort expenditure.

See also  Ted Lasso Spoilers: Cast Member Reacts To Character's 'Shock' Death

A breakdown by insurance market segment shows that commercial lines carried a considerably larger share of the costs than personal lines. Commercial insurance accounted for USD $377.73 billion in 2023, while personal insurance represented USD $202.01 billion. This placed commercial lines at almost two-thirds of the overall total.

Triple-I also highlighted the financial burden falling on organisations and individuals without traditional insurance coverage. Self-insured and uninsured parties incurred USD $163.25 billion in tort costs during 2023, equivalent to 28.16% of the national figure.

Tort costs refer to the economic expenditure associated with a country’s civil justice system when providing remedies for harm caused by another party. The measure includes compensation payments and other related costs arising from civil legal proceedings.

In considering the reasons behind the increase, Triple-I pointed to several developments within the US legal system. These include higher settlement amounts, legal system abuse, increased advertising by plaintiff attorneys and the growing use of third-party litigation funding. The organisation also identified nuclear verdicts and the widening interpretation of liability as factors contributing to greater uncertainty and rising legal defence expenditure.

According to Triple-I, these pressures are particularly relevant to product liability claims, commercial litigation and mass tort proceedings, where the financial consequences can extend beyond individual cases and affect the wider insurance market.

Sean Kevelighan, Chief Executive of Triple-I, commented: “Legal system abuse has economic consequences that extend well beyond the insurance industry. Businesses and consumers ultimately bear these costs, making greater transparency and fairness in the legal system essential to improving insurance affordability and supporting greater stability.”

See also  US cyber rates drop 32% at April 1, bespoke solutions surge amid ample reinsurance capacity: Gallagher Re

Triple-I’s findings underline how the increasing cost of civil litigation can have implications beyond insurers’ claims expenditure. Higher liability costs can also affect businesses through increased insurance expenses, while consumers may face the consequences through more expensive cover.

The organisation’s analysis places particular emphasis on the relationship between litigation expenditure and insurance affordability, highlighting the importance of transparency and fairness in legal proceedings when considering the longer-term financial impact on the insurance sector.

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *