Morningstar DBRS calls for federal insurance backstop to strengthen Canada’s quake resilience

dbrs morningstar logo 2

Morningstar DBRS, a global credit rating agency, has raised concerns over the potential impact of a severe earthquake on Canada’s insurance market, identifying federal government involvement in catastrophe insurance as a possible means of limiting financial losses and protecting the sector from widespread disruption.

The agency’s commentary examines the financial consequences of a major seismic event, particularly in British Columbia, Québec and Ontario, where earthquake exposure is concentrated. Morningstar DBRS warned that an exceptionally destructive earthquake could generate claims beyond the capacity of some property and casualty (P&C) insurers, increasing the possibility of multiple insolvencies.

Despite these risks, Canada has yet to establish a federal insurance mechanism that would share catastrophic earthquake losses with private insurers. Morningstar DBRS explained that the country’s existing approach depends largely on commercial insurance arrangements and the Disaster Financial Assistance Arrangements (DFAA) programme, through which the federal government supports provincial and territorial disaster recovery efforts.

The ratings agency indicated that these measures differ from a dedicated insurance backstop, which could provide additional financial support when earthquake-related claims reach extraordinary levels. By distributing a portion of extreme losses beyond the private insurance market, such an arrangement could ease pressure on insurers’ balance sheets and reduce the likelihood of several companies experiencing financial difficulties simultaneously.

Morningstar DBRS further suggested that federal participation in catastrophe risk-sharing could contribute to greater continuity across the insurance market following a major disaster. The proposed approach could help insurers meet policyholder obligations, preserve confidence in insurance coverage and limit the wider economic consequences of extensive earthquake damage.

While recognising the financial strength of Canada’s insurance industry, the agency emphasised that existing capital reserves would not necessarily shield insurers from the effects of an exceptionally costly seismic event. Significant claims payments could erode capital buffers, weaken insurers’ financial positions and lead to adverse credit rating decisions.

See also  Progressive renews property cat reinsurance program with $2.19bn Florida cover

Morningstar DBRS nevertheless noted that Canadian P&C insurers are subject to robust regulatory capital requirements and have measures in place to manage their exposure to natural catastrophes. These safeguards support their ability to respond to a range of severe events, although the agency cautioned that an earthquake of unprecedented scale could test even the industry’s strongest participants.

“We note that the insurance industry is more than prepared to support its policyholders under a variety of stress conditions,” added Victor Adesanya, Senior Vice President, Global Insurance & Pension Ratings. “However, a catastrophic earthquake could significantly strain the capital resources of even the strongest Canadian property and casualty insurers. A government-supported insurance backstop would strengthen financial resilience and help support the stability of credit ratings.”

According to Morningstar DBRS, introducing a federal insurance backstop could provide an additional layer of financial protection against extreme earthquake losses, complementing insurers’ existing capital and risk management arrangements. The agency considers such a framework potentially beneficial for limiting insurer failures, safeguarding claims-paying capacity and reducing the risk of credit rating deterioration following a catastrophic event.

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *