Frequent acquirers better placed to achieve insurance M&A goals: Oxbow Partners and InsurTech NY

oxbow partners logo

Insurance companies with established acquisition programmes may be more successful at securing the anticipated benefits of mergers and acquisitions (M&A), according to a joint study by Oxbow Partners, a specialist insurance management consultancy, and InsurTech NY, an organisation supporting connections between insurers, technology businesses and investors.

The report, Getting Insurance M&A Right, examines the factors contributing to underperformance in insurance transactions and considers how businesses can improve their approach to acquisitions.

Oxbow Partners and InsurTech NY assessed 333 publicly listed insurance carriers and gathered perspectives from industry executives and transaction specialists with experience of significant insurance deals.

Their research identifies seven areas in which acquisition strategies can encounter difficulties, potentially limiting the financial and operational benefits expected from a transaction.

According to the organisations, problems can begin when insurers pursue potential targets without sufficiently defining the commercial reasons for an acquisition. Inadequate due diligence can create further complications, particularly when assumptions about a target’s performance, market position or potential synergies are not thoroughly examined.

The study also points to the consequences of delaying integration planning until a transaction has been completed. Oxbow Partners and InsurTech NY suggest that decisions concerning how businesses will operate together should form part of the initial assessment of a potential acquisition.

Other concerns highlighted in the research relate to differences in corporate culture, the departure of important employees, inconsistent communication with stakeholders and insufficient management resources dedicated to integration.

The final area identified concerns the measurement of results after a deal closes. The organisations found that a lack of clearly defined performance measures and continued monitoring can make it difficult to determine whether an acquisition is delivering its intended benefits.

See also  Insurers better prepared to deal with disease outbreaks since COVID: AM Best

The research indicates that insurers with greater experience of completing transactions are generally better equipped to navigate these challenges. Oxbow Partners and InsurTech NY attribute this partly to the development of established procedures, specialist expertise and clearer responsibilities across the acquisition process.

For insurers that make acquisitions less regularly, the report suggests that building the necessary expertise in advance could reduce the difficulties associated with managing an unfamiliar transaction.

Manmeet Singh Bawa, Partner at Oxbow Partners in New York, commented: “Acquisitions can give insurers access to new markets, capabilities and sources of growth, but completing a transaction is only the beginning. The real test is whether the organisation can translate the deal thesis into measurable value.

“The evidence shows the importance of experience and preparation. Insurers that build their M&A capability before they need it put themselves in a much stronger position when the right opportunity appears.”

The study presents acquisition readiness as a continuing business responsibility rather than something that begins when a suitable target becomes available.

Oxbow Partners and InsurTech NY suggest that insurers can strengthen their approach by establishing acquisition criteria, identifying potential capability gaps and putting processes in place to assess proposed transactions consistently.

“Major buyers tend to be strategically led. There are shockingly few financially driven deals. There are deals that on paper make a lot of sense, but they don’t get done because it’s not strategically in focus,” added a Senior Advisor, multiple transactions.

The organisations also emphasise the need to connect decisions made before an acquisition with the operational changes required afterwards, ensuring that expected benefits remain measurable throughout the integration period.

See also  Gillian Anderson Addresses 'Unfortunate' Salt Path Controversy

Developed using Oxbow Partners’ advisory experience in insurance strategy, business transformation and M&A, alongside InsurTech NY’s network across the North American insurance technology market, the report concludes that preparation and organisational capability are important considerations for insurers seeking to improve acquisition outcomes.

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *