Hunger Games: Sunshine On The Reaping Reviews Can’t Agree If The Film Is ‘Thrilling’ Or ‘Dreary’

6b0024e6180000a12d94ca7d

The latest addition to the Hunger Games cinematic universe has arrived in cinemas – but whether or not the odds were in the filmmakers’ favour remains to be seen.

Set a quarter-century before the events of the first movie, prequel number two Sunrise On The Reaping focusses on Katniss Everdeen’s eventual mentor Haymitch Abernathy, played in the original by Woody Harrelson while in this instalment, he’s portrayed in his younger days by Joseph Zada.

Joseph Zada as a young Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping

In addition to Joseph, the film boasts an all-star cast playing alternate versions of Hunger Games characters, including Elle Fanning as Effie Trinket, Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman, Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee and Ralph Fiennes as Coriolanus Snow, while new characters are played by the likes of Mckenna Grace, Billy Porter and Glenn Close.

The question is… is it actually any good? Well, that depends on who you ask.

While more favourable reviews have called this latest Hunger Games film a “return to form” and “surprisingly strong”, others have been more critical, branding it “surreally boring” and – ouch! – a “torturous and costly mess”.

Here’s a selection of what the reviews are saying…

“At two-and-a-half hours, Sunrise On The Reaping’s runtime could have used some reaping of its own […] But Sunrise On The Reaping is far stronger than so many fished-from-the-bin franchise revivals.

“The filmmaker [Francis Lawrence] has three other Hunger Games films on his CV, but none with this level of visual assurance (except for some dodgy CGI in the arena).”

The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping takes a deep dive into Haymitch Abernathy’s back story

“A thrilling return to form […] It’s a reminder of just how compelling this world can be when its exhilarating spectacle and deeply human storytelling are firing on all cylinders. With Zada at its centre, Haymitch’s story proves well worth the wait.”

“It’s a mighty 158-minute spectacle, with the franchise’s biggest budget yet. But unusually, the scale helps rather than hinders the film.

“Flaws remain – a dragging middle, a rushed finale – but there’s plenty on offer for even casual fans. Certainly, the performances are enough to keep it compelling as a standalone tale, not too alienating for viewers who’ve not seen, or totally forgotten, the original series.”

“Zada and Grace make likable and appealing Hunger Games players with principles, yet neither of them are as compelling as the previous movie’s semi-doomed lovers Snow and Lucy Gray, nor can Sunrise On The Reaping match that movie’s surprising mixture of folk musical and wartime-espionage noir.

“This one is more of, well, a Hunger Games movie. True to the prevailing Capitol advice, it’s mainly there to put on a good show.”

“Sunrise On The Reaping avoids the pitfalls of Songbirds & Snakes, which struggled to keep its energy up after the bloodbath concluded. The final act of Haymitch Abernathy’s prequel is bracing, ironic, tragic and introspective. At least until the very end, when Lawrence quickly ties off all the loose ends and closes the loop, making any other Hunger Games prequels unnecessary.

Elle Fanning plays Effie Trinket in the latest Hunger Games prequel

“The film is meandering and more than a bit thin, but unlike The Ballad Of Songbirds & Snakes it’s been directed, by Francis Lawrence, in that lavish mode of surface intensity we might now call Hunger Games Classic.”

“The central idea of Collins’ 2025 prequel novel of the same name is that it takes time to seed a revolution. One generation’s failure is the next generation’s fertiliser. In short, keep at it, kiddos. That’s a worthwhile theme. But onscreen, it’s pretty dull. The full arc of Haymitch’s hope, disillusionment and despair doesn’t land with any impact until the film’s strong final minutes.”

“[The film follows] the battle-scarred side character of Haymitch Abernathy – whose function has long been to be unhappy – and are told what made him so titillatingly broken when fans first met him. That might be interesting for those who have followed along from the beginning and are just hungry for more. But to those without any insight into who eventually triumphs over whom decades after all this unrewarding, unrelenting, unromantic failure, Reaping is something else.

“Its framing as a painful, almost universally nihilistic and unrelentingly dour backstory for a single character makes it a deeply strange movie when viewed as a standalone feature.”

“Whether handsome Aussie Zada will survive the unfortunate drawl he sporadically attempts is another matter entirely; I don’t remember Harrelson being this incoherent.”

“This prequel lands at some mid-point between Ballad and Hunger Games, which puts it on an immediately odd footing. It can’t escape the sense of feeling supplementary. It’s an enjoyable-enough diversion, but essentially a footnote with aspirations.”

“These movies seem to be mostly critic-proof and hugely appealing to their core audience, but Sunrise On The Reaping is a dreary slog, another death-march They Shoot Horses, Don’t They? riff with a pretty Gen Z cast, and one that mistakes new layers of darkness (and trauma!) for the sort of profundity that its filmmakers hope will burnish a creatively withering property.”

“When it first appeared in 2012, The Hunger Games seemed fresh and even satirical; now, though, it just feels tired […] there is no sense of peril at all this time, even when Snow finally gets round to getting his drawn-out revenge: The Hunger Games has reached its High School Musical moment where everyone gets a participation prize, and any significant death is obviously just an unfortunate accident.”

“A tortuous, costly mess […] Midway through the movie Haymitch snaps and declares that enough is enough. ‘Let there never be another Hunger Games!’ he roars. Hear hear!”

“Here is yet another iteration of the utterly exhausted, unbearably extended and now surreally boring Hunger Games franchise […] this film has no actual interest and no authentic reason to exist, other than to gouge an income stream out of its fanbase.”

The Hunger Games: Sunshine On The Reaping is in cinemas now.

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *